Your computation is surprisingly erroneous-COCOBOD hits back at Mahama over cocoa price criticism

The Ghana Cocoa Board (COCOBOD) has hit back at former President John Dramani Mahama for criticizing the government’s decision to increase the price of a bag of cocoa to GH₵1,300.

Mr. Mahama in a Facebook post described the government as “insensitive” and a rip-off of hardworking cocoa farmers, saying that the increase was not enough.

He lamented that the government has chosen to offer farmers a mere GH¢1,308 per bag, which constitutes only 52.7% of the Free-On-Board (FOB) price on the international market.

“Sadly, the government has chosen to give them a paltry GH₵1,308 per bag, which constitutes only 52.7% of the FOB Price of the product on the international market.”

Mahama insisted that this is unfair to cocoa farmers who have faced increasing challenges since the NPP assumed office in 2017.

Mahama pointed out that during his tenure in 2016, his government, in addition to the free fertilizer and free cocoa seedlings program, allocated cocoa farmers 66.06% of the FOB Price of cocoa.

In response, the Chief Executive Officer of COCCOBOD, Joseph Boahen Aidoo in a statement on September 12, noted Mahama should be familiar with the process for determining the producer price of cocoa.

Mr Aidoo explained that in 2023/24, the crop was sold between October 2022 and March 2023 at international prices ranging from $2,200 to $2,400 per tonne.

“Since you have had the privilege of being in government before as the number one gentleman of the country, it is expected that you would be familiar with the process for determining the producer price of cocoa.

“I am, therefore, surprised that you chose, rather erroneously, to use the current international market price of cocoa at $3,600 per tonne as the basis for your calculation in your post on the recently announced producer”.

“You are fully aware that Ghana’s cocoa beans are mostly sold forward. This means that the 2023/24 crop was sold between October 2022 and March 2023 at international prices; ranging between $2,200 per tonne and $2,400 per tonne. The international price of cocoa then began to increase in April 2023, when a greater percentage of the 2023/24 crop had already been sold,” the statement indicated.

Read the full statement below

GHANA COCOA BOARD Date: 12 TH SEPTEMBER 2023
ALL MEDIA HOUSES
OPEN LETTER TO FORMER PRESIDENT JOHN DRAMANI MAHAMA
Dear Mr. Mahama,
I have read your post on social media following the announcement of the Producer Price of cocoa, and it has become imperative to address certain misconceptions and misinformation arising from your post. While advocating for the welfare of our hard-working cocoa farmers is essential, it is equally important to approach the issue in
good faith and consider the broader context before passing judgement. Since you have had the privilege of being in government before as the number one gentleman of the country, it is expected that you would be familiar with the process for determining the producer price of cocoa. I am, therefore, surprised that you chose, rather erroneously, to use the current international market price of cocoa at $3,600 per tonne as the basis for your calculation in your post on the recently announced producer price.
Reasons
1. You are fully aware that Ghana’s cocoa beans are mostly sold forward. This means that the 2023/24 crop was sold between October 2022 and March 2023 at international prices; ranging between $2,200 per tonne and $2,400 per tonne. The international price of cocoa then began to increase in April 2023, when a greater percentage of the 2023/24 crop had already been sold. …More
2. The forward sale strategy enables COCOBOD to give farmers a guaranteed producer price and raise the syndicated loan offshore to pay farmers promptly for their produce.
3. The international price of cocoa as alluded to is quoted on a CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight) basis, which includes insurance and freight, albeit COCOBOD receives only the FOB price (which is the cost of beans only). Insurance and freight are received by the insurance companies and shipping lines respectively.
4. Additionally, Mr. Mahama, Ghana produces both the Main Crop size category of beans (big-sized cocoa beans) and the Light Crop size category of beans (small-sized cocoa beans). The light crop beans are sold at a discount; ranging from 20% to 40% on the international market. The FOB price received by COCOBOD from the international market is therefore the weighted average price of both the main crop and light crop beans. This situation depresses the average weighted FOB price received by COCOBOD for the two crop categories (main and light crop beans)
which form the basis for the determination of the producer price for cocoa.
5. For the 2023/24 season, the weighted average FOB achieved by COCOBOD was $2,600 per tonne.
6. Contrary to your assertion that the producer price of GH₵1,308 per bag for the 2023/24 season is paltry, the current producer price translates to $1,821 per tonne, which is 70.03% of the Gross FOB of $2,600 per tonne.
7. In the 2015/16 season, the NDC-led administration announced a producer price of GH₵6,800 per tonne. This was 61.71% of the gross FOB of $2,900 per tonne at the time, not the 66.06% as you alluded. This cannot be said to be better than the 70.03% achieved for the 2023/24 season. It is significant to note that the operational cost of COCOBOD for the 2023/24 season is about 4% of the gross FOB, hence, the rest of the share of the FOB goes into industry costs, LBC margins, and transportation. Generally, the operational cost of COCOBOD has hovered around 4% to 5% of gross FOB since the NPP took over the government. …More
It is also worth noting that the government, through COCOBOD, has invested heavily in productivity-enhancement programmes such as mass spraying, pruning, hand pollination, rehabilitation of diseased farms and subsidized fertilizer programmes. The implementation of the productivity-enhancement programmes has led to an
increase in the productivity of cocoa farms from an average of 450 kilos per hectare in the 2015/16 season to an average of 650 kilos per hectare in the 2022/23 season. This has led to an increase in the income of cocoa farmers.
It is my considered view that this explanation would be a useful guide and source of information in your future engagements on the topic. Your friend and former colleague,
HON JOSEPH BOAHEN AIDOO
CHIEF EXECUTIVE
…###
ISSUED BY:
PUBLIC AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT